Skip to main content
Health Insurance Penalty

Why I Chose to Pay the Health Insurance Penalty and What it Really Costs

My experience buying health insurance in the United States has been frustrating. In 2014 I had two options: I could pay my portion of an employer-sponsored healthcare plan or shop around for a plan through the Health Insurance Marketplace. Otherwise, I would be uninsured and face the dreaded health insurance penalty.

My employer at the time provided a range of plans, however, I could only afford the high deductible plan (HDHP) at roughly $200 per month. After reviewing the policy I realized that for $2,400 per year I could essentially only visit the doctor for preventative care checkups. That’s about it. Nearly every other medical service was paid out-of-pocket, towards the deductible and up to the maximum out-of-pocket amount ($6,350 during 2014). Thus, a major medical expense would likely have to exceed $8,750 for me to receive a benefit ($2,400 in premiums + $6350 maximum out-of-pocket). But I was still scared of the prospect of being uninsured, and justifiably so. A major medical event can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

I resolved to purchase a different HDHP through the Health Insurance Marketplace. After being granted an income-based credit towards my premiums, my health insurance was reduced to $120 per month, saving me $80 for roughly the same coverage. Or so I naively thought. The notoriously unreliable Kaiser Permanente website would not allow me to auto-debit payments or pay online. Each month I was forced to call and wait on hold for up to 20 minutes to verbally authorize payments. Then, because my income fluctuated throughout the year, my credit was retroactively revoked and I had to repay it at tax time. I didn’t receive any medical care in 2014.

In 2015 I decided, albeit foolishly considering the risk of catastrophic medical events, to cancel my health insurance. No more monthly calls, no premiums, no more irritation. I would remain as healthy as possible and limit the risks I can control. At tax time I paid the penalty and still saved $1,750. So, also foolishly, I decided to spin the wheel again for 2016. But 2016 didn’t go as smoothly as 2015 as I had some minor medical concerns and because I wasn’t insured, I found myself avoiding medical evaluations.

So as I turned 30 at the end of 2016, I decided to make a change and patch up the last gaping hole in my finances. I enrolled with my new employer’s health plan and though it’s still through Kaiser Permanente, now I won’t have to deal with their horrific payment system. On a related note I recently tried to register for my new Kaiser plan online but upon submitting my registration information three times (on two computers), I was consistently directed me to an “unknown page.” I had to call Kaiser to register and, as if part of some kafkaesque fever dream they immediately asked, “are you aware of our online portal?”

I was hesitant to write about my experiences with health insurance because it exposes some major flaws in my risk mitigation planning. However, I think it’s important to be forthright about why I decided to go uninsured. I was able to maximize my immediate savings and had no healthcare needs from 2014-2016 but it came at the risk of losing everything. Fortunately I didn’t have to pay the real consequences for being uninsured. With a growing family, it’s not a risk I can afford to take anymore.

So there it is, I say farewell to the last vestige of my care-free and foolishly optimistic youth and fully initiate myself into world of supposedly responsible adults.

Here’s How the Health Insurance Penalty is Assessed for 2016 and 2017

The health insurance penalty is calculated either as a percentage of your household income or on a per person basis and you pay whichever yields the highest bill.

Percentage of income

  • 2.5% of household income upto a maximum of the amount of total yearly premiums that would be required for an average priced Bronze plan.

Per person

  • $695 per adult and $347.50 per child under 18 upto the maximum of $2,085

Paying the Health Insurance Penalty

  • Using the percentage method, only the part of your household income that’s above the yearly tax filing requirement is counted.
  • Using the per-person method, you pay only for people in your household who don’t have insurance coverage.
  • If you have coverage for part of the year, the fee is 1/12 of the annual amount for each month you (or your tax dependents) don’t have coverage. If you’re uncovered only 1 or 2 months, you don’t have to pay the fee at all.
  • You pay the fee when you file your federal tax return for the year you don’t have coverage.

* Source: healthcare.gov

4 thoughts on “Why I Chose to Pay the Health Insurance Penalty and What it Really Costs

  1. We need a lot more articles like this one.

    The combination of a brief overview of the effects of a particular policy with a bare-bones cost analysis is like a one-two punch to the brain. Figuratively! I could envision a book of 151 of these, Sign me up!

  2. Even though you never know what could happen in the course of the year, you took a risk I might have taken myself – being young and healthy and saving your hard earned dough. Kudos on being so forthright with your decision!

    1. Thanks Matt,

      It all works out in retrospect but I am glad I didn’t get hurt or unexpectedly ill in the two years I wasn’t fully covered. I also made the decision when I had a pretty large cash reserve; though definitely not enough for a significant hospital stay.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *